Trafford or Pickford: what the numbers say about England’s goalkeeping choice
The Leeds goalkeeper’s late saves in Madrid have reopened the debate, but Thomas Tuchel insists England do not have a No 1.
James Trafford was one of England’s best players in the 3–2 win over Spain. With England down to ten men, he made a double save in stoppage time, first from Fermín López and then from Mikel Oyarzabal’s follow-up, and also kept out efforts from Lamine Yamal and Marc Cucurella.
The case for each goalkeeper
Experience is on Jordan Pickford’s side. The Everton goalkeeper, 32, has 94 caps, more than any England goalkeeper except Peter Shilton, and 372 Premier League appearances. Trafford, 24, has five caps.
This season’s form points the other way. Opta figures quoted by Sky Sports show Trafford has conceded eight Premier League goals from 12.40 expected goals faced, the best goals-prevented record in the league. Pickford has conceded ten from 11.05, which is also better than average. Their save percentages are similar.
Trafford has not been perfect against Spain: he has conceded four goals in his two appearances against them in this group, Sky Sports noted.
What they said
Tuchel would not name a first choice after the game. “There’s no No 1,” he said, adding that Trafford “had a brilliant match” and that England “want competition in all positions.”
Before kick-off, Roy Keane said on Sky Sports that picking Trafford was “smart management” and that “there’s not much between them.”
What happens next
England do not play again until March, when the Nations League quarter-finals begin. Both goalkeepers have four months of club football to make their case.